Fake news may be Mister, Do It With Me, Not With Momtrickier for young internet users to spot than previously believed.
A new study from Stanford University found that even members of generations purported to be the most web-savvy of all time are often tripped up by deliberate misinformation online.
SEE ALSO: 7 signs the news you’re sharing is fakeThe researchers behind the report tested thousands of students ranging from middle schoolers to college kids on their ability to pinpoint obvious political biases, basic signs of credibility and sponsored content tags.
They found that the young people by and large failed their age-appropriate tests for news literacy.
"Many people assume that because young people are fluent in social media, they are equally perceptive about what they find there," Stanford education professor Sam Wineburg, the lead author of the report, said in a statement. "Our work shows the opposite to be true."
The findings come as the spread of intentionally false news online has dominated media discussion in the wake of a presidential election in which it seemed to hold more sway than ever on public opinion.
After several days of denying his platform was part of the problem, Facebook CEO Mark Zuckerberg recently rolled out a comprehensive plan to strengthen the social network's defenses against such stories that relies in large part on vigilant users identifying and reporting them.
But if even the most supposedly web-fluent users have trouble sorting out hoaxes and misleading sources — as the study indicates — it seems Facebook's strategy may not go far enough.
The authors of the study used a host of separate tests to determine their subjects' news judgment, each designed to fit students' respective academic levels. The material encompassed social media feeds, comment sections, blog posts, photographs and any other digital media with the potential to influence the students' outlook on a political issue.
In one test, middle schoolers were asked to differentiate between native ads — branded posts designed to camouflage with other content — and actual news articles on the Slatehomepage. Of the 203 students interviewed, more than 80 percent failed to notice the sponsored content marker.
That finding shouldn't come as too much of a surprise; several other studies have found that web surfers of all ages have trouble with this distinction.
"Young people’s ability to reason about the information on the Internet can be summed up in one word: bleak."
Another test asked high school students to choose the more credible of two tweets — one from the verified Fox News account and another from a handle that closely resembled it. Three quarters failed to note the significance of Twitter's blue checkmark certification, and three in ten said the fake account seemed more legitimate because of its graphic design.
Around four in ten high schoolers also believed a thinly sourced photograph of wilted flowers on the photo-sharing site Imgur was strong evidence that the disaster at Japan's Fukishima Daiichi nuclear plant caused “nuclear birth defects” based on the headline alone. Less than a fifth gave responses that indicated "mastery" of the news value, according to the study's rubric.
Meanwhile, college students — a sample that encompassed attendees of highly selective schools like Stanford and big state universities — were expected to evaluate the validity of various websites with more nuance. Yet the study found that more than nine out of ten of respondents were unable to recognize a front website for a lobby group posing as a reputable news site, faring even worse than Advanced Placement high school students given the same test.
Overall, students consistently underperformed researchers' expectations in the vast majority of the tests.
"Young people’s ability to reason about the information on the Internet can be summed up in one word: bleak," the authors wrote in an introduction to the study.
Despite a growing number of courses now purporting to teach media literacy across different grade levels, it seems that tactics used to spread deliberately fake news and the blending of advertising with editorial content may be outpacing educators' abilities to warn students of them.
As big digital platforms like Facebook and Google crack down on the abundant fake news within each of their sites, the study suggests that lessons may be needed at a more fundamental level in order to effectively combat the problem.
Topics Google
Twitter's backend is breaking under Trump's tweetsBeyoncé's Grammys performance was magical perfection, obviouslyDead mic silences James Hetfield at the Grammys, but Lady Gaga saves the dayNew docuseries shows what life is really like for queer and trans men of colorBlue Ivy Carter wore a perfect tiny pink suit at the GrammysFord announces $1 billiom investment in Argo AI selfBeyoncé's Grammys performance was magical perfection, obviouslyThis cosplayer might be the most convincing Taylor Swift lookalike yetBlue Ivy joins James Corden for Carpool Karaoke, rendering previous Carpool Karaokes irrelevant4 solutions to the iPhone 7's dongle crisisI love social media, even if it doesn't love me backKate McKinnon's Kellyanne Conway goes full 'Fatal Attraction' on 'SNL'This blimp that looks like a butt is the largest aircraft in the worldHarvard Book Store trolls the Trump administration with its new section4 solutions to the iPhone 7's dongle crisisBeyonce's Grammy acceptance speech was a powerful message to the children of the worldYou'll love Katy Perry's Grammys performance unless you're Donald TrumpCassie the robot improves bipedal walking balanceValve is worried about the effects of Trump's travel banHere are all the winners of the 2017 Grammys Writers Remember Ronald Reagan Our Candy Print Makes the Perfect Valentine’s Day Gift Sadie Stein on Disney’s 1935 Silly Symphony “The Cookie Carnival” See the Salacious Covers of the Books Georgia Tried to Ban 'Disaster Girl' meme NFT sells for $500,000 at auction Boring Prose to Help You Fall Asleep Céline and This Walking Cup of Ramen Both Know True Hardship TV shows to watch (and finish) on a flight What is Google's new unknown tracker alert? Remembering Maxine Kumin by Dan Piepenbring Public companies now have to report data breaches within 4 days The Morning News Roundup for February 12, 2014 'Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles: Mutant Mayhem' review: Action The Hidden History of Warren G. Harding Why a Long Train Ride Is Perfect for Writers Instant Happy Woman by Sadie Stein Twitter aka X changes ad labels, makes promoted tweets less obvious Nastia Denisova’s Window on the World The Morning News Roundup for February 20, 2014 Sadie Stein on R. S. Thomas’s poem “Luminary”
2.8471s , 10130.9140625 kb
Copyright © 2025 Powered by 【Mister, Do It With Me, Not With Mom】,Charm Information Network