The psychotherapy and eroticismTrump voter is often portrayed in media and pop culture as a working-class white person, down on their luck and desperate for change. These voters were -- and remain -- willing to look past Trump's erratic and unorthodox behavior and "politically incorrect" commentary if his presidency brings better jobs. These voters, the narrative goes, are in pursuit of a noble life, even if the man they chose to be commander-in-chief is neither generous or honorable.
But a new study, published Monday in Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, argues that a segment of these voters was motivated partly by a far less righteous cause: to protect their own dominant status in American culture and politics.
SEE ALSO: The Trump administration is hellbent on erasing the reality of people's livesThe study looks at a nationally representative group of the same voters who cast ballots in 2012 and 2016. In particular, it focuses on those who voted for Barack Obama and then, four years later, supported Trump. Instead of finding voters nervous about their family's finances, it uncovered deep concern related to America's declining global power and the projected demographic changes that will put people of color and ethnic minorities in the majority by 2045.
"What we find is this sense of threat."
"What we find is this sense of threat," says Diana C. Mutz, the study's author and professor of political science and communication at the University of Pennsylvania.
Mutz found no evidence that personal economic anxiety, represented by indicators like worry about retirement savings, medical bills, and education expenses, predicted greater support for Trump. She also asked about the state of voters' personal finances and whether their community had high unemployment and a concentration of manufacturing jobs. Meanwhile, Trump's supporters favored a smaller safety net, which suggests they're less concerned about how people will fare when they face dire financial straits.
One particularly telling factor did increase the likelihood of support for Trump: believing that white people are more discriminated against than people of color, and believing that Christians and men experience more discrimination than Muslims and women.
Mutz also found that the people who switched their vote from Democrat to Republican between 2012 and 2016 were more aligned with Trump's aggressive stance on free trade and China's ascendance as a global superpower. And they expressed a desire for group hierarchy instead of equality, with their group on top.
Other studies since the election found that racial attitudes played a role in Trump's election. Mutz says her analysis, which uses high-quality panel data as opposed to cross-section survey data, suggests that people are more threatened by the accelerating achievements of black people rather than the negative stereotypes they may hold.
Her findings should provoke uncomfortable conversations about the complicated ideas and beliefs that motivated people to vote for Trump. In fact, these are debates many people of color, including those in the media, have engaged in since well before Trump was elected.
But for the past year-and-a-half, many reporters and pundits have crafted the prevailing narrative, which is rooted in sympathy for Trump voters. Roseanne Barr, for example, has taken this campaign into people's living rooms with the reboot of her show, which tacitly defends its support of Trump based on the economic salvation he represents for white working-class Americans. This idea was front-and-center in Sen. Ted Cruz's recent tribute to the president in Time: "President Trump is a flash-bang grenade thrown into Washington by the forgotten men and women of America."
Imagine instead, though, a media narrative that took seriously the notion that voters chose Trump as a way to protect their own dominant status — not as an act of noble rebellion. It might help explain, for instance, the shockingly high approval rating the president still has with evangelical Christians. And yet, that debate is fraught because it points to deep-seated bias and prejudice.
"It's a really difficult conversation for people to have. Most people don't want to perceive themselves as racist."
"It causes people to confront things that are uncomfortable and unflattering," says Andra Gillespie, an associate professor of political science at Emory University who was not involved in Mutz's research. "It's a really difficult conversation for people to have. Most people don't want to perceive themselves as racist."
It is indeed easier to point to just about any other thesis for Trump's victory, including Hillary Clinton's various weaknesses as a candidate and her campaign's mistakes. And while Mutz's findings represent one aspect of Clinton's loss, they are arguably the hardest to face.
They also present a daunting challenge for liberal activists hoping to mobilize support for Democrats in this year's midterm elections. There are certainly ways Democrats could strategically tailor their message to address people's concerns about China and globalization, but there's no realistic way for the party to reassure voters interested in protecting their status without betraying its base: black people and progressive allies, who believe that nothing short of full equality and equity will suffice in the 21st century.
Even if the Democrats nominate a flawless presidential candidate in 2020 — as if such a thing exists — it's entirely possible certain voters will still be eager to march to the polls, ready to defend their place on top. No matter how easy it is to pretend that fight is about pocketbook anxieties, it's increasingly clear it's instead over who gets to wield the most power in America. That is a battle we simply cannot ignore.
Topics Activism Social Good Donald Trump Politics
Of course Snoop Dogg has no time for Donald Trump's weird tweetsThe best ways to solve your new holiday tech problemsAustralia's 1.2Climate change has greatly impacted the world in 2019McDonald's Twitter account just dropped some fire on Donald Trump (and then deleted it)Sorry cord cutters, Sling TV just raised its pricesIncredible photos capture 'Ring of Fire' in the final solar eclipse of 2019'The Mandalorian' Chapter 8: 5 big takeaways ahead of Season 2The legend behind that powerful lightsaber in 'The Mandalorian' finaleThe feud between Britain and Sean Spicer is getting ridiculousWhy Apple, Google, and other big tech companies create their own fontsNearly every drone would be tracked under new FAA ruleSuperhero comics creators: we're political, and always have beenAll our burning questions after 'The Rise of Skywalker''Rise of Skywalker' is Star Wars' past. 'The Mandalorian' is its future.This is the best way to give cash as a gift without being totally boring'You' Season 2 finale: What the hell just happened?Cool blue phone cases inspired by Pantone's color of the yearVolkswagen built a robot that can find your electric car in a parking lot and charge itIt's time to talk about how Star Wars treated Chewbacca like crap Swole Jeff Bezos joins Instagram to tease his new ROCKET FACTORY Then and Now: Six Generations of $200 Mainstream Radeon GPUs Compared Google 'Ask for me:' AI that calls businesses on your behalf for pricing and availability Best free gift card deal: Get $10 Best Buy gift card with $100 Apple gift card Best LG B4 OLED TV deal: Save $200 at Best Buy NYT Connections Sports Edition hints and answers for February 15: Tips to solve Connections #145 GPU Availability and Pricing Update: April 2022 NYT Connections hints and answers for February 5: Tips to solve 'Connections' #605. They met on Tumblr, and their relationship outlasted their accounts Sri Lanka vs. Australia 2025 livestream: Watch 1st ODI for free Best MacBook deal: Save $200 on 2024 M3 MacBook Air Trump says he represents Pittsburgh, not Paris, but, um, well... The Year in Tech: 2014 Top Stories Apple's newest ad makes a haunting plea to take climate change seriously Celtic vs. Bayern Munich 2025 livestream: Watch Champions League for free Will Oracle take over TikTok? Trump says he'll make a decision in 30 days Greenpeace activists charged after unfurling 'Resist' banner at Trump Tower in Chicago China just built the world's biggest floating solar project How to Get Your Significant Other Into Gaming Report: Match Group dating apps conceal assault cases
3.5366s , 8288.3359375 kb
Copyright © 2025 Powered by 【psychotherapy and eroticism】,Charm Information Network