A showdown is Peggy Markoffbrewing in the U.S. courts, one that pits young Americans against President Donald Trump and the fossil fuel industry.
Central to the fight is a lawsuit that accuses the federal government and energy companies of failing to adequately address human-caused global warming. A group of 21 citizens, ages 9 to 20, claim that failure violates their "constitutional rights to life, liberty and property."
Now Trump and fossil fuel defendants want the case to go away.
SEE ALSO: How 21 kids could keep climate websites from going completely darkBoth groups filed separate motions last week to the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals to scrap an earlier ruling that upheld Juliana v. United States. It's unusual for the government to try to appeal a case to a higher court before a lower court has ruled on it -- especially since this case is moving toward a trial later this year.
This Tweet is currently unavailable. It might be loading or has been removed.
Environmental groups and some climate scientists have praised the children's lawsuit as a groundbreaking strategy to force the government to act on climate change.
The lawsuit initially targeted former President Barack Obama who, for all his efforts to tackle climate change, still couldn't shake the nation's dependence on oil, coal and natural gas. Now Trump has inherited the lawsuit. But unlike Obama, Trump says he doesn't believe climate change is a threat. His EPA administrator, Scott Pruitt, is working to dismantle the climate policies that Obama put in place.
If successful, this first-of-its-kind lawsuit could force even a skeptical government to curb carbon dioxide emissions and help communities adapt to the effects of global warming. Hence all the attempts to stop it.
The Trump administration filed a motion on March 7, disputing the earlier ruling that the children have a viable legal claim.
In November, U.S. District Court Judge Ann Aiken denied the Obama administration's motion to dismiss the lawsuit -- setting a landmark precedent for climate issues as legal rights.
This Tweet is currently unavailable. It might be loading or has been removed.
"I have no doubt that the right to a climate system capable of sustaining human life is fundamental to a free and ordered society," Judge Aiken said in her decision.
The Trump team also filed a motion to delay trial preparations until after the court considered the appeal. On top of that, lawyers asked for an expedited review of both motions, citing a Jan. 24 letter filed by the young plaintiffs' lawyers.
That letter -- a legal preservation notice -- requests that federal agencies and fossil fuel industries retain records relating to climate change and any communications between the government and oil, gas and coal companies.
Lawyers filed the letter after it seemed likely the Trump administration would remove global warming-related content from the websites of the Environmental Protection Agency, NASA and other agencies.
This Tweet is currently unavailable. It might be loading or has been removed.
The Trump administration called the letter "extraordinarily broad," saying it placed an outsized burden of discovery on the federal government. The United states could be "irreparably harmed" without a stay, the administration claimed in its motion.
On March 10, fossil fuel industry groups filed a similar motion requesting appeal of Judge Aiken's decision. The defendants' attorneys also claimed the companies would be forced to spend "enormous" resources to produce all the documents and witnesses required in the expert discovery phase.
Julia Olson, a counsel for the 21 young plaintiffs and executive director of Our Children's Trust, said the Trump administration's efforts to quash the lawsuit demonstrate the government's "misplaced priorities."
"They're right. It is a big case," she said in a statement. "They prefer to minimize the procedural obligations of not destroying government documents over the urgency of not destroying our climate system for our young plaintiffs and all future generations?"
Topics Donald Trump
Samsung's Live Translate will be available on thirdWeChat integrates AI Search with DeepSeek, seeks to allay concerns over user privacy · TechNodeMaichi Network issues apology and removes Pokémon: Reborn after lawsuit · TechNodeXiaomi to invest $4.2 billion in R&D development in 2025 · TechNodeDeepSeek announces openA colossal asteroid once boiled the oceans. It also did the unexpected.Scientists watch hardcore object blasting energy beams into spaceMaichi Network issues apology and removes Pokémon: Reborn after lawsuit · TechNodeThe space station has a risky leak. How bad is it?En route to an asteroid, spacecraft snaps ghostly views of EarthSamsung Unpacked 2024: Sydney Sweeney, Tomorrow X Together, and more make cameosTarget Circle deal: $200 Westinghouse Smart Roku TViPhone 16e to feature A18 chip with TSMC’s 3nm process and custom 5G chip · TechNodeWebb telescope spots extremely bright objects. They shouldn't be there.Early Prime Day deal: $110 off Shark cordless stick vacuum (IX141)Samsung devices get Circle to Search with translation and homework helpDeepSeek announces openJBL tune headphone deal: $39.95 at Amazon'House of the Dragon' Season 2, episode 4: Pay attention to the dogs at HarrenhalTrump won't stop making a deceptive bird claim. Experts debunk it. Nothing Is Alien: An Interview with Leslie Jamison The Disappearing Face of New York by Dan Piepenbring On Knowing Things What We’re Loving: Dead Poets, Dead Magazines, Dead Zoo Gang Peter Matthiessen, 1927 I tried TikTok's viral lettuce water sleep aid. It was kind of gross and I slept horribly. Hinge, Tinder, OkCupid encourage UK daters to show COVID How to watch Premier League soccer in the U.S. in 2023 An Interview with Jenny Offill Read Frederick Seidel’s Poem “Arabia” Wordle today: Here's the answer and hints for August 8 'Barbie': Where to buy Kate McKinnon's Weird Barbie doll The FCC just fined a robocall company $300 million The Morning News Roundup for April 4, 2014 Happy Birthday, Donald Barthelme Good Taste by Sadie Stein The Morning News Roundup for April 1, 2014 Google Search can check your grammar now Donald Trump killed his recently created blog and honestly that's a very blogger move Dave Jorgenson's TikTok book is a fun, engaging read for aspiring TikTokkers
1.6891s , 10130.625 kb
Copyright © 2025 Powered by 【Peggy Markoff】,Charm Information Network